i would say
Duelist - Aspas/Derke
Initiator- Leo/Sacy
Controller - TenZ/Mako
Sentinel - Alfajer/Less
Flex - Chronicle
IGL - Boaster/Saadhak/FNS
Firstly Mako >>>> TenZ (as a controller, mechanically probably not)
You really picked TenZ as the best controller all time over the likes of Marved, Mindfreak, Karon, Boo, Valyn, Shao (Shao smokes on FPX was good), Kingg, Pancada?
The Omen one trick over arguably some of the best all time smokes players, hell I'd even say SugarZero all time is a better smokes player (bros been top 5 apac controller for like 4 years now) than TenZ
Shao's smokes are kind of amazing, but then again I also think his initiator is possibly even better - that dude is just insane. Kind of weird how navi fumbled with Suygetsu & Shao on the team.
Bit of a tangent anyways, but yeah as a controller Tenz was not even close to being in goat status. Also, no RB or Forsaken for flex is kind of insane (or even Victor D4v41 or Zyppan)
Derke/Aspas
Leo
Mako
Less/nAts
Chronicle
Boaster
i think Leo is pretty clear of Sacy conversations and pANcada/tenz each only have half the body of work as Mako. Less vs nAts interesting peak vs longevity argument. Derke and Aspas are really hard to differentiate from each other but if I personally had to pick I'd take Derke's longer career. Boaster's made one more LAN and did better with worse players imo than saadhak
Don’t care about team based trophies I care about individual play. If you disagree you’re objectively wrong. Oxy hasn’t made a single major in his life and still clears icy, asuna, qck, marteen, autumn, izu, whyz, governor, kai and arguably far more of the duelist that made majors in 2024. If you can’t comprehend that you’re clueless.
i would say
Duelist - Aspas/Derke
Initiator- Leo/Sacy
Controller - Mako
Sentinel - Alfajer/Less
Flex - Chronicle
IGL - Boaster/Saadhak
man now that I look at this list I look back on 2023, where both of these rosters existed (mako was on arguably peak DRX at the start of the season too)
A good 2025 and FNS is back on the list
If GENG make 2 more deep runs in 2025 I think Munchkin also goes on the list