0

Ban system is fucked no?

Comments:
Threaded Linear
#1
WhatADrag

The team from the upper bracket has an insane advantage going into a veto, essentially banning the opponent's two best maps. That is fucked, ngl. Maybe I am biased because Sentinels is coming from lower, but had it been PRX, I still would have been mad. This needs a change.

#2
SAMPV6
8
Frags
+

Yeah it's pretty bad, but I guess upper finalist does deserve some advantage... idk if this is it tho

#3
WhatADrag
-15
Frags
+

Yes, they do, but giving them 2 bans???? That is insanity. Just give them the normal advantage of choosing team A or team B to get the first ban

#5
ASTEROIDCHILD
30
Frags
+

that's not enough tbh, getting to grand finals undefeated deserves a valid bonus because technically every other team had two chances. if u go to grands from uppers then lose it's like you only had one chance

#12
JustHunterM8
3
Frags
+

Why is that insanity? The better team will win regardless of the maps that's what it takes to be a world champion. That's why lower bracket runs are so looked up upon, because they're genuinely hard and impressive and when someone accomplishes it it should be celebrated.
That's how it goes in sports man. The one thing I don't like is the 1 day turnover which gives the upper bracket team a rest day where the lower bracket team just played the prior day. Sometimes its a double edged sword but typically it forces the lower bracket team to go through a grueling schedule and disadvantage to win the tournament.
It is what it is tho, Sen still gonna win cause they're the better team

#15
tuffybass
3
Frags
+

no that's hardly even enough. want to make it fair make then make sen beat them twice since it's double elim. 2 map bans isn't even enough of an adv

#22
WhatADrag
-6
Frags
+

A two-map ban not enough???
They get an extra day to prac
They get an extra map ban
They get the first pick

The upper team indeed deserve an advantage, but that advantage should be something other than a guaranteed win for them. And the argument that Sen should beat them twice since it's double elim is just not it.

#36
finnwithtwons
2
Frags
+

guaranteed win LMFAOOOO go check what happened to paper rex... TWICE... then come back
(edit just saw a comment saying upper finals winners have only won twice to lower bracket winners winning four times... please write out the words guaranteed win again for me)

"just not it" go look at what every other serious competition that uses double elim brackets does and let us know what you find out you're going to find a very consistent trend

#40
tuffybass
1
Frags
+

lmfao one extra day of prac like they haven't practiced every day for the last 3 months at least. they haven't lost, whoever they play in final has. first pick is very minimal advantage. upper team either needs an very good advantage or they need to have to lose twice, i'm fine with the bans, i think its enough, but anything less than that is troll otherwise teams could lose and save strats if they were confident against lower final team and not be out anything in final

#41
finnwithtwons
0
Frags
+

guaranteed win is now 5-2 historically in favour of LB winners btw
unsurprisingly you are full of it

#28
zhongZHI
3
Frags
+

just curious would u be complaining if it wasnt geng but sen who won?

#29
KaedeTsuneta
1
Frags
+

obv not

#30
WhatADrag
-3
Frags
+

reread my question.
Had it been PRX I still would have complained.
I had same thought last year when EG was facing PRX

#34
shaq_attaqr
1
Frags
+

what was your thought last year after eg beat prx 3-1?

#4
shaq_attaqr
5
Frags
+

I mean you deserve a huge advantage for winning through uppers, usually in games that don't take 4 hours for a bo5 the team from lowers straight up has to win twice. My issue with double map ban is that how good it is really depends on how much the top 2 teams' map pools overlap, look at how effective it was in tokyo vs champs for example

#6
Siigma777
5
Frags
+

Not losing at all you deserve an advantage like that. It's not nearly as big as an advantage as it seems though, just look at PRX vs EG last year.

#23
WhatADrag
0
Frags
+

EG was just built differently at that point. They deserved to win no matter what. But I guess that is not a correct argument here because if a team win a world champion then its obvious that they are built different.

#37
finnwithtwons
0
Frags
+

if sen loses tomorrow and people say they "deserved to win but lost because of map ban rules" then why didnt they win in upper finals?

#7
moshimoshiman24
5
Frags
+

its pretty fair tbh bc u should deserve a advantage for coming from upper bracket. most esports are single elim. the ones that r double elim make the upper bracket start 1-0. even with this advantage tho many times the team from lower bracket won ex fpx 3-2 prx at coppenhagen optic 3-0 loud at reykjavik

#8
PENTAKIM
5
Frags
+

It is a double-elimination tournament with no bracket reset. So if GenG loses one time at grand final, do they get a second chance like sentinels? I think a team coming from the bottom bracket should be happy that they don't get a map advantage instead.

#9
moshimoshiman24
1
Frags
+

no this is the grand final no matter if gen g loses or not thats y gen g get the map veto advantage

#25
WhatADrag
0
Frags
+

So if GenG loses one time at grand final, do they get a second chance like sentinels

This is not a legitimate argument. It doesn't matter if they lose or not. They made the upper final run. The same could be said in Kick off-tournament of Americas. EG and NRG won everything in the upper bracket of their group, but they lost their playoff game.

#10
Costofequity
5
Frags
+

no bracket reset

usually to be fair lower bracket needs to win 1 bo3 and then another bo5

#11
trikecycle
4
Frags
+

It’s better than the alternative of a bracket reset

#13
Targu1n
0
Frags
+

bracket reset would be a fun thing to try for VCLs, but yea a bo5 bracket reset is rough (and I dont think anyone's gonna argue for a bo3 grand finals)

#14
Cromawarrior48
-6
Frags
+

kinda fucked cause upper team already getting more prep time which is advantageous

#16
tuffybass
3
Frags
+

then win

#17
altsright
-1
Frags
+

No.

#18
CoCloudy
4
Frags
+

its not that much of an advantage
paper rex had that advantage on both grand finals
and lost both

#32
Cromawarrior48
1
Frags
+

cause prx r chokers

#19
finnwithtwons
0
Frags
+

its honestly an underpowered advantage, every other team has the cushion of the double elim which the other team in the final has used to even get to the final in the first place, the team that goes through winners loses that opportunity
if you want true fairness then we should make things even stronger for the team that goes through winners by giving them a bracket reset like a lot of systems do, but valorant doesnt do that because it would take an obscene amount of time

#20
Tsikhamani
0
Frags
+

It's simply, stop whining and win the upper bracket finals to get the advantage!!

#26
WhatADrag
-2
Frags
+

LMFAO. This is just a conversation, not trying to sign a petition to reduce the advantage. No wonder Indian teams don't make it to LAN.

#38
Tsikhamani
-1
Frags
+

I accept south Asia are bad in valorant and last year an Indian org called Orangutan made it to ascension lan last year.
And PRX won the upper bracket finals in copenhagen 2022 and in LA 2023 and still lost the finals with the Advantage and what you wanna prove with it??

#21
Hidero_
1
Frags
+

That's the point of winning the upper bracket, you get an advantage

#24
canyon
4
Frags
+

tell me valorant is your first esport without telling me valorant is your first esport

#27
ButterflyEffect23
1
Frags
+

flair KEKW

#31
Nbs
9
Frags
+

At the end of the day, 2nd chance at a tournament is much better than any other advantage that upper finalist gets

#33
Alexsei
0
Frags
+

playoffs should be single elim why do we give losers a 2nd chance?

#35
Karmine_Org_WhispeR
1
Frags
+

Not really. If the Upper bracket finals winner has 0 advantage in grandfinal (e.g. 2 map vetos) they’ve pretty much gotten 0 advantages throughout the whole tournament.

It really just comes down to which team is better. I mean just look at grandfinal history in vct except for lock in, icelands 2021, and champs 2021. Envy had a map veto vs Gmb but still lost 3-0, Loud had two map vetos and got 3-0 by optic, Prx had two map vetos and still lost to fpx, Prx had 2 map vetos vs EG and still lost to EG.

Upper bracket finalists had only won two times vs lower bracket finalists

4:2

#39
makesung
0
Frags
+

It’s so normal because then why u need to win in upper while u can win in lower that makes every match is important to win and if ur team is good enough u can win ( like EG won PRX 3-1 Champ2023 )

  • Preview
  • Edit
› check that that your post follows the forum rules and guidelines or get formatting help
Sign up or log in to post a comment