How Tf did aka fuck up this story
0
Oshi no ko ending
posted in
Off Topic
Comments:
Threaded
Linear
saynotoherpes [#2]90% of mangas are written by antisocial weirdos and its always only a matter of time before they fuck up and fumble it all
What's a mango
saynotoherpes [#2]90% of mangas are written by antisocial weirdos and its always only a matter of time before they fuck up and fumble it all
my favorite manga of all time is made in abyss yet I cant even read it anymore because the author is letting the weirdness seep in to art again, seriously wish they had an editor that has the balls to tell him to become normal
Totally_not_a_altt [#3]What's a mango
fr fr? mango mango? like the drippy still water? on thick of it? balkan rage mode???
j3bx5597 [#4]it is a good ending your just a hater
it ain’t the worst ending itw but it’s not a good ending that’s for sure 😂. This ending was so lazy and unsatisfying
saynotoherpes [#8]fr fr? mango mango? like the drippy still water? on thick of it? balkan rage mode???
PUT THE STILL WATER DOWN!!
geospliced [#10]Literally so infuriating considering how the rest of it was a masterpiece (in my opinion). I feel like they could've done so much more with it but instead of giving closure to like... all the characters they just [insert moral message about persevering] and call it a day.
i think u misunderstood the ending.
ruby still has black star eyes, indicative of her trauma - she's still lying to herself saying that she has healed etc. she won't really move on from either trauma she experienced
the rest of the characters make sense:
kana: had to be kept pure/in the light so she reacted the most viscerally to aqua's death bc she was meant to bring him out of his dark persona. though she only accepted the lies presented to her by aqua
akane: willing to do anything for aqua, accepted the liar behind the lies. while morally ambiguous she will recover the best out of the 3 main girls
also you have to understand that the harem/incest subplot was always bait, the fact that aqua died this way and ended up with none is to be ironic
j3bx5597 [#15]i think u misunderstood the ending.
ruby still has black star eyes, indicative of her trauma - she's still lying to herself saying that she has healed etc. she won't really move on from either trauma she experiencedthe rest of the characters make sense:
kana: had to be kept pure/in the light so she reacted the most viscerally to aqua's death bc she was meant to bring him out of his dark persona. though she only accepted the lies presented to her by aquaakane: willing to do anything for aqua, accepted the liar behind the lies. while morally ambiguous she will recover the best out of the 3 main girls
also you have to understand that the harem/incest subplot was always bait, the fact that aqua died this way and ended up with none is to be ironic
I don't think I misunderstood the ending, I think I simply didn't say enough in my original comment to convince you otherwise. I guess I was mainly referring to the last chapter because I was really looking forward to it and it didn't deliver the way I wanted it to.
Also, incest is quite blasphemous and I really did not like that part of the story, and being a romantic reader I actually prefer it when the protagonist ends up with someone instead of uhhh... expiring right at the end.
geospliced [#16]I don't think I misunderstood the ending, I think I simply didn't say enough in my original comment to convince you otherwise. I guess I was mainly referring to the last chapter because I was really looking forward to it and it didn't deliver the way I wanted it to.
Also, incest is quite blasphemous and I really did not like that part of the story, and being a romantic reader I actually prefer it when the protagonist ends up with someone instead of uhhh... expiring right at the end.
not meeting expectations != a bad ending.
i agree that incest is morally reprehensible. ayasaka sensei is wry enough to bait it throughout the manga. hes the kind of guy to ironically put it in, but never commit to that premise.
geospliced [#10]Literally so infuriating considering how the rest of it was a masterpiece (in my opinion). I feel like they could've done so much more with it but instead of giving closure to like... all the characters they just [insert moral message about persevering] and call it a day.
honestly the last like... 40 odd chapters have just led up to absolutely fucking nothing
the only constant is how good mengo's art is
j3bx5597 [#17]not meeting expectations != a bad ending.
i agree that incest is morally reprehensible. ayasaka sensei is wry enough to bait it throughout the manga. hes the kind of guy to ironically put it in, but never commit to that premise.
Endings to stories are subjective and to me, not meeting expectations when the rest of it had been so enjoyable makes it a most disappointing ending.
I do respect your thoughts and where you're coming from.
jixk [#11]the first episode was its own movie tbh and after i watched i heard about the incest manga thing so i stopped while it was good
there was no incest manga part but aight lmao
I really can’t tell if this is a good ending or a bad ending. It’s realistic to some extent, but good or bad is up for interpretation.
It’s realistic because revenge always begets tragedy and there is (usually) never a good outcome.
+++Aqua dying left a lot of loose ends, and while his death was tragic, it impacted everyone.
However, my main gripe is that Ruby essentially became Ai 2.0, even though it was stated that she wanted to become her own “idol,” though she has surpassed Ai to some extent. The whole “lies will become someone’s truth” is a good concept but it wouldn’t really be Ruby’s “style.”
My ideal ending would’ve been to coincide Aqua’s revenge to the Dome performance so there’s a lot more emotional depth from every character, and it would culminate to that final arc.
Oh well, still a fun read.
redlight [#23]I really can’t tell if this is a good ending or a bad ending. It’s realistic to some extent, but good or bad is up for interpretation.
It’s realistic because revenge always begets tragedy and there is (usually) never a good outcome.
+++Aqua dying left a lot of loose ends, and while his death was tragic, it impacted everyone.
However, my main gripe is that Ruby essentially became Ai 2.0, even though it was stated that she wanted to become her own “idol,” though she has surpassed Ai to some extent. The whole “lies will become someone’s truth” is a good concept but it wouldn’t really be Ruby’s “style.”
My ideal ending would’ve been to coincide Aqua’s revenge to the Dome performance so there’s a lot more emotional depth from every character, and it would culminate to that final arc.
Oh well, still a fun read.
i think the writer limited himself when doing that
Discord