Not one of the best players currently, but when he was the best, he sure is not overrated because the rating speak for itself. Like it's not even people speaking but the data speaking. Just try to find it. "wasn’t outstanding that much" is not the word I would used when he's top 3 most rated players in most events, get stopped by LOUD through duo of aspas and cauanzin before Champ 23 but that's like peak performance, and keep up top 1-3 performance with very high K/D before leaving.
I would not hype him for the present, but also not disregard him for the past when it can hardly argue from looking at the data. Because then I would have to disregard like 50% of EMEA players or 50% of all Tier 1 players just from rating alone. Think of TH and how would you rate Benjy in that team. it was like that in the last time he played against them.