For me its actually pretty mid no cap. She could've done better. Lavender haze and maroon are the only good songs in the album. All of the other songs lacked lyrics and aren't produced well enough.
probably like a 3? it had a couple good songs in there, but it's just way worse than her last couple projects (which, for context, i'm not a huge fan of). i feel like Jack Antonoff kinda killed the record, his production style gets blander and blander by the minute. I hope he stays away from Pheobe Bridgers and, for the sake of pop music, Billie Eilish