START hating on koi
Brawk is absolutely better than soulcas. soulcas has been one of the worst players in emea for years and it's truly shocking that he still is even in tier 1. If I had to guess it's due to experience because in both fragging and utility usage Brawk clears him.
Sheydos has been performing worse than Ethan lol. And Ethan has been historically better too, whereas sheydos peaked in 2021 and has just been serviceable at best ever since. Ethan was great in 2021 and 2022, one of the best players in the world in 2023 and pretty good in 2024. But more importantly, sheydos has a 0.84 rating in emea, which is quite bad. whereas ethan is 1.01, which isn't great but not bad either and definitely way better than sheydos.
S0m vs grubinho is definitely way more debatable. grubinho was fantastic in 2024 but has been mid so far this season. s0m is one of the best players in NA and is performed well in kickoff. the reason this is a debate is how much you value a 3 game sample size, because grubinho was truly a great player last year and will most likely turn up in the season. So for this one you convinced me to change to: grubinho=s0m
Overall tho, you are pretty wrong about your rankings and it is clear you are pretty biased because based on stats this year your points are easily refutable.