We are not robots, eye test is way more important than stats. Sometimes players are on dysfunctional teams and are put in positions where they can't frag out.
In a vacuum, your statement is correct, but you're too delusional to admit that it doesn't apply to shao or suygetsu at all.
In fact, you quite literally explained yay's situation in a nutshell.
Everyone who is saying they agree with this post don't realize the context in which he is saying: shao > yay
https://www.vlr.gg/285053/who-would-you-rather-have