Of the main roles in pro team (duelist, initiator, controller, sentinel, flex), what role do you think works best for IGLing?
“I don’t think teams should have a true igl. Just get 5 elite players and teach one to igl mainly for the beginning of rounds”
This is extremely stupid and what I was disagreeing with. Cohesive midrounding is one of the most important aspects of competitive play, and why a central IGL is so important. Too many voices will do nothing but cause confusion and conflict.
Igl’ing stops being “we go B this round guys” once you get past iron
Edit: you edited your response, but allow me to clarify what I meant
A team needs a voice to make all final decisions. Obviously other player’s input is important.
Also comms vids are not representative of a team’s true environment… they need to hide strats, reads, etc.
There's actually a difference between coordinating entry and mid-round calling.
The mid-round call mostly comes from the IGL (even though not always, depending on IGL style and how much leeway is provided for the rest of the players to make adjustment calls based on info received).
The execute coordination is mostly done by the first 2-3 players entering the respective area/site (in CS is more related to the numbers, in Valorant the agents usually have an impact on who those 2-3 players are, rather than the "first players on the map").
My feel is controller or initiator. Initiators usually kickstart plays, so they need to have the feel for where/when to do so. Controllers well... control space better by hiding LOS. They have a wider range of where their utility can reach which means having a wider feel for the entire map is key, something that a good IGL needs. Sentinels are also good at controlling space, but many of them control a small area or specific area and are not able to have a great read on things outside their area until they are fed information from others. The delay in having to be fed the information will build with each proceeding step. I do think it's probably controller that should be doing a lot of the IGLing both preround and pre-exec, but when it comes to actually calling the execs it should probably swap to the initiator or even the duelist since they will have the best read on what they've been running into on site. Then handing it back over to the controller after the exec happens.
I think fnatic is the absolute best demonstration of how good an IGL can be when on the controller role. They can set up on the fly with what kind of fights their teams get into because they have all the control over how map gets cut up during executes.
but if the controller role is taken by gods like mako i'd probably want my IGL on one of the flash initiators. anything else I swear is trolling / praying for it to be a holy shit check his pc kind of day.