| Flag: | Australia |
| Registered: | June 10, 2023 |
| Last post: | December 1, 2024 at 9:00 PM |
| Posts: | 7416 |
To determine if there’s a biological advantage you need to look at the representation of trans players relative to the overall population of bio women within Valorant.
It's like if you had said that people above 5 foot 3 are generally better at valorant than compared with people under 5 foot 3, this is a stupid argument if you're just looking at who is seen doing well in gc. 5 foot 3 people may be proportionally better as if only 5% of val pop is below 5 foot 3 but in pro play 10% of players are below 5 foot 3 then there is a potential chance for there to be biological advantages.
I don't necessarily disagree with you but your generalising the success of all trans people off cherry picked data and you have a lack of understanding of proportional statistics.
Lets be honest, they weren't gonna be picked up by another tier 1 team anyway.
Also, the same thing happened with dapr on sen but no one talks about that.
Its not only due to misogyny but misogyny would still play a pretty large role
Best 7 are:
Bind
Haven
Ascent
Sunset
Split
Fracture
Pearl (I'm starting to hate this map but it's fun to watch)
just because a player improved does not automatically make him the best player in the world.
OMG I HIT SILVER 3 TODAY WHEN YESTERDAY I WAS SILVER 2, SO NOW I'M THE BEST PLAYER IN THE WORLD.
OMG ZEKKEN HAD A 1.5KD AGAINST EG WITH SUBSTITUTES AND ROLE CHANGES IN A MICKEY MOUSE TOURNAMENT.
He is easily the best player in the world for this reason
I wouldn't be so sure about SEN, they are probably going to be top 3 americas but their new roster is definitely still questionable
100%, I find that childhood plays a significant part as to why trans players are seemingly better than bio women on average.
Your lack of biological understanding scares me.
Firstly you claim that X and Y chromosomes depend on the person, parents which are factors seperate from gender when X and Y chromosomes literally determines your sex, I'm assuming you meant sex and not gender here and if u did in-fact mean gender then this would be irrelevant.
I have no idea how you believe that women and men have the same genes when men have half the X chromosomes that women do. Also men have Y chromosomes which includes crucial genes that give them more testosterone which is only found in the Y chromosome.
Genes don't just determine your biological appearence but also your testosterone level through genes such as SRY, and things to do with your personality, also these genes are half from father and half from mother but some genes such as crime linked genes are not the dominant gene meaning that the child would need this crime gene basically twice for the gene to have an affect and be present which does not necessarily need to be present in either the father or mother.
First of all women do have different genes and some genes are found more commonly in men such as different crime genes: There are many studies on this for example here is one: https://www.rsb.org.uk/biologist-features/crime-genes.
so in-fact women do have different genes than men and your ignoring Y chromosomes which account for half of mens genes.
And here is how your hormones affect your cognitive ability: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6422548/
Hormonal balance has been proven to affect differences in cognitive strategy to different tasks so this would be the biological factor if somehow you think genes or other biological differences don't play a role in cognitive strategy and this is assuming cognitive strategy is the only difference between the genders in spatial tasks.
you could pretty much say the same for tenz and sen tbh.
Yes, I'm just stating that on a neutral and inherent level there are biological differences, I never claimed that woman cannot transcend these disadvantages. All I'm stating is that there are biological differences, and obviously this isn't the biggest determinant of the disadvantages that woman face in esports since there are cultural and historical material conditions
Even if there are personality differences that would slightly change how to solve orientation this would still mean men are greater in spatial abilities. Also there is no way to determine if it's cultural/personal factors at play here or if its biological but my assumption is biological. Also they clearly state there are significant differences and the only reason they say mixed is because 1 out of 4 studies found little differences whilst the others found significant or clear differences.
How many biological women are in tier 1?
A review by Emanuele Coluccia called Gender differences in spatial orientation: A review
Reviews many differences cognitive studies between male and females. In this they explain the differences in spatial abilities such as mental rotation tasks and spatial orientation which are both relevant to fps games. This doesn’t include the differences in reaction times.
just because some trans women are better than most most doesn't mean women on average are better than men.
Biological differences like reaction times or spatial awareness are inherent differences seen across the men and women, these are not conditional guarantees however. Just because there are women in Radiant doesn’t mean there aren’t average differences at play.
Using your logic then since a very very small amount of biological women can deadlift 250kg, this would mean that there aren't any biological differences in strength between the genders.
Halpern, D. F. and their book "Sex Differences in Cognitive Abilities,"
One major point she concludes is that men have greater spatial awareness, this is obviously very important in fps games
Mako
KangKang
Primmie
Leaf
Forsaken
Something
Mistic
Alfajer
JonahP
Derke
Bonus: Screwface
I mean this just isnt true but keep preaching
I've seen more people talk about loud then kru, furia and eg combined
NRG gotta stop supplying these addicts with delusion meds.
I acknowledge that some people may find that because potter is a woman then they love her but the question isn't about how much she is loved or attention but is rather about her coaching ability. Frooti is saying “god” coach as in how is she great at being a coach, this is also implied by Frooti's subheader. And so your point about attention is irrelevant to the question.
I understand that people may overrate potter's ability because they appreciate her representation but noomys response implies what you just said about people loving her because of her representation and they overrate her ability at coaching because of this. I find that Noomy thinks that practically all people who love her because of her representation will overrate her ability at coaching then. - I thought that this was not true at all and so nobody would actually believe this so I just assumed that Noomy thought the question was more about why she is loved or disliked.
Discord