EDG and Astralis

now I am not comparing them in terms of goat teams in their games (cuz astralis clears obviously), but I just wonder if you take player for player what roles do they take?
kangkang - device (star player)
nobody - gla1ve (IGL)
any else?

chichoo - magisk (anchor)

smoggy - dupreeh
s1mon - xyp9x aka clutch minister ?

DryseNNN [#3]

smoggy - dupreeh
s1mon - xyp9x aka clutch minister ?

I am legit surprised by one of them being 0-2-7 at one point, like generational impact, is it like normal in valo or is that some peak util?

Nef0r0 [#4]

I am legit surprised by one of them being 0-2-7 at one point, like generational impact, is it like normal in valo or is that some peak util?

it just a normal in valo

DryseNNN [#5]

it just a normal in valo

and am I correct to understand that edg is basically the best china can offer in their separate roles, kinda like astralis was the best danish talent all under one roof?

Bruh Astralis were out of the world in their prime EDG will take atleast 3 more years to reach there if they have consistent performance

MassterBaiter [#7]

Bruh Astralis were out of the world in their prime EDG will take atleast 3 more years to reach there if they have consistent performance

''I am not comparing them in terms of goat teams in their games'' = EDG are way too fresh to be even remotely compared to astralis, I just asked for the general rule of thumb that EDG basically has the best players in one of the most populated regions?

Nef0r0 [#6]

and am I correct to understand that edg is basically the best china can offer in their separate roles, kinda like astralis was the best danish talent all under one roof?

I don't think so