smokes players come

https://imgur.com/a/ty29WQ1

Are these two smokes good smokes on fracture?

(For context no i am not Zellsis word* enough to throw these two smokes on attack, these are defend smokes for retakes only. If im playing close or on site i will just throw a chokepoint smoke, but if im retaking are these two smokes good? obv im not going to throw both of those smokes together cause it will block off site but i feel like they are p good at blocking off certain angles and letting u focusing on others. suggestions are welcomed）

no

There's a sizeable gap on either side of the bottom smoke + the top smoke bulges out which the defenders can use to isolate fights

im not the best smokes player, but id smoke more deep tbh

i'd just smoke canteen and arcade, and a bit deeper.

u gotta at least smoke arcade or canteen

no, those smokes are not good.
https://imgur.com/a/wGcGM0V

No

for these smokes to get value you need to play either in them or just outside them to punish people taking space or killing the planter, and for that to work you either need another smoke for arcade or complete arcade control