Bloodborne

3rd best game of all time (only behind Elden Ring and Outer Wilds)

bloodborne >> elden ring
elden ring bosses are zzz

pokerogue clears

Epicgamer69 [#2]

bloodborne >> elden ring
elden ring bosses are zzz

Look I love Bloodborne to death, but the base game bosses for it are nothing special. Only great ones are Gascoigne, Gehrman, and Martyr Logarius. The rest range from okay to utter shit. The DLC adds Ludwig, Maria, and Orphan of Kos, but that's it. Elden Ring's base game line up is way better.

vollizie [#4]

Look I love Bloodborne to death, but the base game bosses for it are nothing special. Only great ones are Gascoigne, Gehrman, and Martyr Logarius. The rest range from okay to utter shit. The DLC adds Ludwig, Maria, and Orphan of Kos, but that's it. Elden Ring's base game line up is way better.

i disagree. Only notable bosses for me in elden ring was Morgott/Margit and Maliketh. Everything else in my opinion had either poor scaling, bad movesets, ctrl+v, or relied on cheese tactics that rely on you to use summons to make it seem fair.
The DLC bosses shouldn't be written off.. literal peak gameplay, bosses in DLC hard clears Eld0n ring bosses.
That said Comparatively speaking, I just personally think that Bloodbornes bosses are just better in general, I prefer the style of big angry monsters.

Epicgamer69 [#5]

i disagree. Only notable bosses for me in elden ring was Morgott/Margit and Maliketh. Everything else in my opinion had either poor scaling, bad movesets, ctrl+v, or relied on cheese tactics that rely on you to use summons to make it seem fair.
The DLC bosses shouldn't be written off.. literal peak gameplay, bosses in DLC hard clears Eld0n ring bosses.
That said Comparatively speaking, I just personally think that Bloodbornes bosses are just better in general, I prefer the style of big angry monsters.

I disagree heavily. Margit/Morgott and Maliketh were not the only notable Elden Ring bosses. I thoroughly enjoyed fighting Godrick, Radahn, Godfrey, Placidusax, Rykard, Mohg, and Radagon (1st phase). Imo, that's already a stronger line-up than Bloodborne (and that's including the DLC). Not to mention some of the more notable non-Remembrance bosses like Godskin Apostle, Elemer and Commander Niall. Of course there are some stinkers among the crowd like Godskin Duo, Fire Giant, and Rennala, and while I don't think Malenia is bottom-of-the-barrel, I do think her waterfowl dance is unfair. I also acknowledge the amount of repeat bosses in the game is definitely too high (biggest absurdities are Godefroy, sewer Mohg, Erdtree Avatars, and Tree Spirits). I never said it was perfect though. That being said I do think the highs outweigh the lows.