Blud thinks he's cooking, your arguement is IF they change the whole team to a tier 3 roster we wouldn't support fnatic anymore.
Let me help you learn something, if you support an orgnaisation it means you respect the management, the values and also the location of the system.
Fnatic are known for fantastic scouting, management and they have been successful over a long period of time.
Your hypothetical is fucking dumb, because it wouldn't happen and the reason we support the organisation is because we know it's not a stupidly run one. Also they are in a partner league system, where no team in any of the leagues has tier 3 players. They all were a success or had an established tier 2 background - especially in EMEA.
If fnatic weren't winning and they certainly WERE NOT always winning, yes we would still support them. You never have watched any other sports seriously and don't understand what loyalty is or how fanbases work.
You cannot be a fake fan if you were there throughout and are still a supporter it defeats the definition of the phrase. Also who say "checkmate." 🤓 Such a psuedo-intellectual thing to do.